Preserving the Building

Preserving the Building

OUR TRACK RECORD OF PRESERVATION

Over the past century, the women of Sedgeley Club have been responsible for preserving the Sedgeley Club Building and restoring the lighthouse. Preservation of the building has remained at the pinnacle of our priorities for over a century.

Looking back over the last decade or so, this is our record of major preservation projects. Countless other projects – from maintaining the gardens to painting and plumbing have been completed every year by our own Sedgeley Club members.

2008: Ensure the foundation is stable, prevent storm water invasion during major flood eventsDSCN3963

Many of the historic boathouses along the river had noticed sinking foundations and decaying footers – creating stability problems and major safety concerns.  In 2006 the first inquiries about our building’s foundation were made to a structural engineer, followed by a site inspection at Sedgeley Club.   After researching and considering multiple proposals, by spring of 2008 the Board approved a plan to fill in small pockets of lost soil under the building and repair the cracked cement slab outside that lay connecting the river’s seawall and our basement.  On rare occasions when the river has crested the seawall and reached major flood stage, this cracked slab was an entry point for flood water coming into the basement.  At a cost of $17,000, the building was secured from the ground up.

2009: Replace defective windows on back porchDSCN6402

When the river side porch was enclosed in 1959 we added ten large windows.  Fifty years of use and exposure to the elements caused these windows to become loose and fragile. In late 2009 the Sedgeley Club Board of Governors agreed to replace the old windows with architecturally appropriate windows that were safe, energy efficient and approved by the Historical Commission.  The ten old windows became 16 new ones that complemented Arthur Brockie’s architectural plans submitted in 1902. Our cost was just under $18,000.

2009: Paint the house on the riverside

During the window renovations, severely rotted wooden trim was discovered throughout the riverside exterior. The Board approved removing and replacing the rotted trim and then painting the river side exterior of the building before the winter set in. After considering multiple bids, the painting project was approved – and completed at a cost of $10,700.

2009: A Road Map

A professional home inspection of Sedgeley Club was conducted in May of 2009.  The inspection served as a roadmap – telling us what repairs were needed, the approximate cost of each repair and the timeframe in which to complete them.  The inspection revealed a few problems posing immediate danger to the building and the people inside.  On the top of the list was the original knob and tube electrical wiring from 1910.

2010: Replace active knob and tube wiring

Still in use behind our plaster walls, and connected to modern wiring which carried a higher load of electricity, the old knob and tube wiring posed a fire hazard throughout the building.  A second and third opinion from independent electricians confirmed the problem.  In addition, the circuit box in the basement was found to be overloaded, needing updating and a good reorganization.  The Sedgeley Club Board of Governors approved a bid from an electrician who specializes in rewiring old houses in Philadelphia.  His firm came highly recommended, presented a competitive bid and agreed to make additional repairs outlined in the home inspection.  The total cost was $15,595 and all of the work was completed in early 2010.

2010: Insulation of the attic and second floorDSCN3992

After the knob and tube wiring was disconnected we were able to insulate the building.  We completed the project using an Amish firm that produced great results and brought us homemade potato chips to snack on.  The cost was $3,961 including the potato chips.  Our Treasurer was pleased to report that over the next two winters we saved more than the cost of the insulation, thanks to reduced heating oil bills.

2011: Quiet times

During the year of 2011 and into spring of 2012, we rested.  It was quiet at Sedgeley Club except for the routine repairs and maintenance tasks expected with a 110 year old house which we were happy to complete.   

2012: Our front stairs

Stairs - Before

Stairs – Before

Another priority from the home inspection report was ready to be tackled over the summer of 2012.  At the front entrance to the club house, the wooden stairs and landing had soft floorboards and loose railings.  The main beams and posts supporting the structure underneath were beginning to rot. The replacement stairs and landing would have to be approved by the Historical Commission and match the original plans from Arthur Brockie’s drawings of 1902.   After working with the Commission, a plan was approved.  The new plan matched the original design specifications from 1902, yet conformed to current building and safety codes, and allowed some maintenance free material.  The cost of the project was $10,800 from concept to completion.  Volunteers from Sedgeley Club painted the stairs and landing to match the rest of the house.

Stairs - After

Stairs – After

Having first-hand knowledge of what it takes to maintain Sedgeley Club’s iconic building and unique lighthouse for over 110 years, and wanting to preserve them for generations to come, the Board of Governors led by Lois Krombolz, set out to form a non-profit corporation dedicated to preserving the historic building. With pro-bono help from a local law firm, Friends of Historic Sedgeley was created in 2012.  FHS represents a new era of sustainability for Sedgeley Club’s historic building, and opens new possibilities for raising the funds necessary to preserve it.

2014: Kitchens

Early in 2014 FHS and Sedgeley Club shared in funding two projects. The first was replacing the sink, plumbing and cabinetry in the basement kitchen, repairing the ceiling and painting the room. The second project was replacing the first floor kitchen sink, plumbing, flooring and cabinetry. Total cost for both projects came to $7,600.  

2016: New Roof, Gutters and Dormer Siding

Roof leaks were becoming more difficult to repair, and they started occurring in new areas of the house.  It was clear that our roof was failing. 
DSC_0197
After four years of fundraising, with generous help from our friends at J&L Building Supply and our roofer, Hancock Building Associates, of Malvern PA, FHS was able to complete the roof replacement project in April. 
In addition to the new roof, new cedar shakes were placed on the dormer cheek walls, and brand new gutters and downspouts were installed.  The total cost of $33,000 was funded by FHS donations.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           
2017: Extensive Exterior Work and an Exciting Partnership
Collaborating with CertainTeed, and with heartfelt thanks to generous donors, FHS completed our most challenging preservation year to date. FHS replaced old cedar shingles with state of the art manufactured shingles that look like the real thing.  CertainTeed’s Cedar Impressions Individual 5″ Sawmill Shingles were donated to us by CertainTeed and installed by Hancock Building Associates.  These shingles are the first to be approved by the Philadelphia Historical Commission for use on a National Historic Landmark. They provide a consistent historic look to our boathouse, are windproof, waterproof, maintenance free.


FHS also restored the exterior wood trim to it’s original condition.  Removing a century of paint – performed by Old Village Master Painters –  revealed beautiful wood trim handcrafted for the boathouse. Finally, FHS hired WMG Historic Restoration to restore eight original windows (including original glass) to their pristine 1902 condition.


2018: A Wrap-Up Year for the Exterior

FHS replaced the cracked and sloping sidewalk, installed a gated fence by the seawall and restored some interior walls and ceilings where plaster had cracked over time.

2019: Replacing the Boiler

Aside from improving visitor safety and access to the lighthouse, FHS undertook a large project in 2019 with generous donations from two donors. FHS was able to repair two chimneys and replace the old oil tank and boiler with a new energy efficient natural gas-powered boiler. In late 2019, FHS replaced the rubber roof surrounding the lighthouse tower. This project completed the list of exterior repairs. 

2020: Pandemic and Projects

While the world began to cope with the SARS Covid-19 Pandemic, businesses, including Sedgeley Club were not permitted to host indoor events.  With our doors closed, we used this quiet time update the Main Dining Room and entry way.  Quickly raising funds from members and friends of Sedgeley Club, FHS completed the renovations before opening up again in 2021.

2021: A Partnership with the Commonwealth

Thanks to a matching grant called the Keystone Historic Preservation Grant from the Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission (PHMC) FHS completed a critical structural repair project. One section of the building was sagging in the same location on all three levels. With help from PHMC, FHS hired a crew to dig beneath the basement floor, and uncover the foundation walls and footers.  Here a section of foundation wall had settled lower over time and caused the structure above it to be pulled downward. The settled wall was repaired and fortified, then covered again.  On the top floor the drop in elevation was over three inches on just 10 feet of floor. After exposing the floor joists, we discovered severe cuts were made in the original joists.  These cuts, made decades ago during plumbing repairs, weakened the joists and exacerbated the sagging conditions.  The crew repaired and sistered each joist, making them stronger and removing the sag.  The electric and plumbing had to be replaced, and new flooring was needed. In about five months, the entire structure was renewed; made safe and strong again. Friends of Historic Sedgeley is immensely grateful to the Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission for making these critical repairs possible. 

You’ve seen what we’ve done over the past decade; now have a peek in to the Preservation To-Do List for the future…